The Best Mystery Flavor Snacks and Drinks for an Exciting Surprise
Are you bored with your usual snacks and drinks? You can have an exciting surprise with every bite or sip with a mystery flavor.
Usually, these flavors might have a "tutti frutti" taste, but some brands have been stepping it up with unexpected flavors for Halloween. Because, after all, there isn't anything spookier than knowing what you're about to taste.
In preparation for the scary holiday, continue reading to discover our favorite mystery-flavored eats to shake up your snack time.
Laffy Taffy Mystery Swirl Rope: $0.40
Of course, we had to start with something classic, like Laffy Taffy's Mystery Swirl Rope. This version of the candy combines two flavors into one fruity delight. And as you've always known, it has that delicious chewy texture that always gets stuck in your teeth.
Airheads Theater Box Candy: $1.29
One of the most popular mystery flavors we've seen is this one from Airheads. To us, it tastes vaguely like a tropical punch drink. We've heard it combines all the leftover flavors, so every time you purchase one, it has different notes. It truly is a mystery!
Also read about: The Best Apple-Flavored Snacks to Taste Test This Fall
Dots Mystery Ghost Gummy Candy: $1.99
Something spooky has been brewing at the Dots factory—their new ghost gummies have arrived. Inside this box, you'll find five flavors: strawberry, lemon, lime, cherry and orange. But you won't know what you're eating until you pop one into your mouth.
Jelly Belly Beanboozled Mystery Dispenser: $5
The Jelly Belly Beanboozled was our childhood, and we're excited that they're still around in 2024.
This fun set will challenge you and your friends to a roulette. You might think you're trying Juicy Pear when it is actually Booger, or your Birthday Cake bean might hold a Dirty Dishwater flavor.
XO Marshmallow Trick or Treat Mystery Flavors: $10+
You've been missing out if you haven't seen XO Marshmallow on TikTok. They have almost every flavor you can imagine. This Halloween, they're offering a mystery box to give you one of their limited edition offerings. There are a variety of choices, from Cereal Milk to Blueberry Cobbler.
OLIPOP Ridge Rush 12-Pack: $35.99
Meet OLIPOP's newest flavor, Ridge Rush. According to their product description, it's an "exhilarating fusion" of flavors to energize you for your next adventure. Technically, it's not a complete mystery (with official notes of lemon, lime and orange), but you'll be in for a surprise if you see this in stores without context.
Still hungry? Click HERE to discover our definitive ranking of everything you can put in your Chipotle order.